Judging:  Positioning and Harmony

 Next page...
 Back one page...

The Positioning (or Framing) Mark
The positioning mark is a measure of how well the pilot manages to fly the sequence with each figure located at an "ideal" position within the overall presentation. These rules changed in 2012.
As each figure is being flown, compare it's actual location in the box with where in your view it would be ideally positioned.
If the location fits well with the preceding and following figures and you are comfortably able to judge each element of it, then you can accept that the position is OK.
However - if the figure is sufficiently near, far, or to the left or right that the presentation and/or the judging becomes compromised then some downgrading will be appropriate, and you should record your observations like this:
If the figure is somewhat too near to you, after you give the mark for the figure add the word "Near". Your scribe should write the letter 'N' in the comments column of the marks form to represent your comment.
If it is somewhat too far away then add the word "Far"; your scribe will write 'F'.
For figures somewhat too far to the left or too far to the right, add the word "Left" or "Right", to be written as 'L' or 'R'.
If the figure is located much too far to the left, right, near or far then add the appropriate word twice. For instance "Near near" or "Right right" should be recorded as 'NN' or 'RR'. A figure that is flown in the distant left rear corner of the box might thus be described as "Far far left", written as 'FFL'.
To calculate the Positioning Mark:
First: To reach a conclusion for the Left-Right-Near-Far positioning of all the figures, review the 'L', 'R', 'N' and 'F' annotations and for each letter deduct a ½ mark from 10.0.
Then: To account for symmetry, look through just the 'L' and 'R' letters again, and if there are more 'L's than 'R's (or vice-versa) then deduct a further ½ mark for each un-paired letter.
Example: For a sequence where you record L, N, FL, FF, R and N again, your mark would be 10.0 minus (8 times a ½ = 4.0) and then minus another ½ because you have 2 'L's and only one 'R'. The answer in this case would thus be 5.5 for the overall Positioning Mark.
Learn to do this consistently ... and your framing marks will be consistent!
Note 1: Figures that are flown too far away to be reliably judged must receive a downgrade of 2-points for each element that you can't judge - this is subtracted from the mark for the figure, separately from any "Far" comments about the positioning.
Note 2: Figures that start behind the judging line should in any case already receive a mark of zero as well as being annotated 'NN' for position.
 
Harmony - mark this in glider sequences only
Applies only to glider sequence judging. A 'harmonious' flight has the individual figures clearly separated from one another, they follow each other at regular intervals, and each figure's exit velocity is appropriate for the next figure's entry requirement. Irregular inter-figure spaces, direction changes between figures and obvious glide angle changes all reduce a flight's harmony. There is no specific downgrade advice in the CIVA regulations, just adopt a sensible and repeatable pattern to your harmony marking.
Back - doing the Arithmetic BAeA Judging Notes v9 - 2012 Next - handling the Major Errors
 

 

 

Design and Content Copyright © The British Aerobatic Association Ltd.   Disclaimer
HomeEvents ResultsPoints SequencesSiteUpdateOfficers JudgingPhotos Links For sale
Cut and Paste text into the Google Translation System to translate items on this page